Running Bias-Free Performance Calibration Meetings
Designed for Experienced people managers in fast-scaling tech organizations tasked with running quarterly performance calibration meetings involving cross-functional peers. to spark real collaboration and high-energy learning.
A 90-minute hybrid workshop with managers who have some experience in performance discussions but are under pressure to align ratings quickly and avoid conflict. Most are wary of being perceived as unfair or ‘biased’ and want tactical support on leading inclusive, defensible meetings.
Bias Bingo Icebreaker
Kick off with an interactive ‘Bias Bingo’ card (physical or virtual) featuring subtle, real-world calibration meeting quotes (e.g., ‘She’s just really likable’ or ‘I can always count on him to stay late’). Participants find someone who’s heard or said each phrase.
Tap to view the full activity.
Why this works
Making bias detection playful primes curiosity and lowers defensiveness, opening minds to learning without blame.
Bias Mythbusters Poll
Run a quick-fire poll with statements like ‘Having more people in the room makes calibration fairer’ or ‘Bias only creeps in when people are tired.’ Reveal instant group results, then debunk with quick evidence and stories.
Tap to view the full activity.
Why this works
Directly addresses misconceptions that block bias mitigation, creating cognitive dissonance for learning.
Judgment-Free Bias Spotting
Present anonymized, composite calibration comments (‘Alex consistently exceeds goals’) and ask everyone to secretly jot down any possible bias or alternative perspective. Then, invite volunteers to share with no wrong answers.
Tap to view the full activity.
Why this works
Invites everyone to participate at their own pace, ensuring even those hesitant to speak up can engage.
The Calibration Hotseat
Energize the room: Two facilitators role-play a tense calibration exchange (one subtly biased, one calling it out). Challenge the group to ‘buzz in’ with flags (real buzzers, chat emojis, or hand-raises) whenever they spot a bias in action.
Tap to view the full activity.
Why this works
Creates an emotional jolt and peer validation of bias spotting, cementing awareness through participation.
Stakeholder Dilemma Swap
Present a real-world dilemma: ‘You’re moderating a calibration session. A peer insists their report deserves a top rating, citing ‘leadership presence,’ but data is mixed. What do you do?’ Small groups each get a stakeholder card (HR, peer manager, skip-level leader, underrepresented employee) and must advocate that viewpoint.
Tap to view the full activity.
Why this works
Forces learners to wrestle with competing perspectives, building empathy and robust bias-mitigation strategies.
Bias Reflection Commitment
Invite participants to reflect individually: ‘Think back to your last calibration meeting—what’s one bias you now recognize, and how will you actively counter it next time?’ Each writes a private commitment, then (optionally) shares in pairs or through a digital board.
Tap to view the full activity.
Why this works
Personalizes learning, ensuring transfer by connecting insights to real intentions and next actions.
Sign up to unlock 3 more activities
Get the full pack, facilitation flow, and more ready-to-run ideas.